Carnegie Council Logo
 
SEARCH:  
   PEOPLE    ADVANCED
THEMES PROGRAMS CALENDAR RESOURCES SUPPORT US ABOUT US
Print Page Mail Page
 
Resources
  Transcripts
  Audio
  Video
  Ethics & International Affairs Journal
  Current
  Back Issues
  Carnegie Ethics Online
  Articles, Papers, and Reports
  Other Publications
  For Educators and Students
  Global Ethics Corner Videos
  Resource Picks
  "To Be Read" Book Review Column
  RSS
 
 
Carnegie Council Podcast
Carnegie Council RSS


eNewsletter Signup
Please enter your email address to subscribe to the Carnegie Council email newsletter.
 
 
 
Most Emailed Pages
1. Expanding Europe: The Ethics of EU-Turkey Relations [Full Text]
2. Iran and the United States: David Speedie Interviews Gary Sick
3. Implementing Women’s Human Rights in Malaysia
4. Business and Human Rights in Conflict [Excerpt]
5. When Parks and People Collide
 
   
     
 

Counterfactuals and the Proportionality Criterion [Abstract]
Ethics & International Affairs, Volume 20.4 (Winter 2006)
David Mellow

 
     
 

November 28, 2006

In addition to having a just cause, a resort to war or use of military force must be proportionate in order to be morally justified. In this essay, Mellow argues for the need of a counterfactual baseline with moral qualifiers when making the proportionality evaluation. In defending his proposal, he also contends that the relevant goods and harms that are weighed in the proportionality evaluation are not as open-ended as is sometimes presumed.

To read or purchase the full text of this article, click here.



 
 

About the Journal

The Carnegie Council's flagship publication, Ethics & International Affairs is an interdisciplinary resource for scholars, students, and policy analysts concerned with the moral dimensions of global issues. The journal covers global justice, civil society, democratization, international law, intervention, sanctions, and related topics.

SUBSCRIPTIONS
To subscribe to Ethics & International Affairs, or to purchase individual issues and articles, go to Wiley-Blackwell.

RESPONSES
The Editors welcome responses to Features and Essays published in Ethics & International Affairs. To be considered for publication, responses should be no longer than one thousand words, including endnotes (which should be kept to a minimum). Responses are not peer-reviewed, and are published at the Editors' discretion. All responses are subject to editing for length and style. In the event of any questions or substantive editing, the response will be returned to the author for final approval prior to publication. Responses are published online, alongside the article they address.

Related

Biography
David Mellow
 
Keywords
Security, Warfare, Peacekeeping, Just War
 
 
 

Resource Highlights

Global Ethics Corner: Market Capitalism Questioned
Global Ethics Corner
  Will people associate U.S. power with "global misery" or with the opportunity and pluralism that Obama's victory represents?
> More
Fixing Fragile States
Fixing Fragile States
  Devin Stewart interviews Seth Kaplan on his new book, which lays out a new paradigm for development.
> More
> All Audios
New from Policy Innovations Online Magazine
Policy Innovations Online Magazine
  "Corporate Social License and Community Consent," by Keith Slack.
> More
Ethics & International Affairs
Ethics & International Affairs
  Go to the Journal for articles on ethics and foreign policy.
> More